OutdoorMaster Ski Helmets Review: Good Enough…But Is Good Enough Good Enough?

Active Gear Review is supported by its audience. If you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Ski helmets are one of those purchases where your brain and your wallet argue with each other. Your brain says spend the money, get the good one. Your wallet says it’s just a helmet, how different can they really be? OutdoorMaster is squarely in the “wallet wins” category, and after a number of full ski days testing the DIAMOND 2 MIPS and the ELK MIPS at Caberfae Peaks in Michigan, we can tell you exactly what that means.

Our female tester wore the ELK MIPS while snowboarding. Our male tester skied in the DIAMOND 2 MIPS. Across multiple days, temperatures ranged from a relatively pleasant 31°F down to some face-stinging teens, giving us a pretty solid spread of conditions to test them in. Here’s what we found.

First Impressions and Build Quality of the OutdoorMaster Ski Helmets: What You’re Actually Holding

Pick up either of these helmets and hold them next to a SMITH, a Giro, or a Ruroc. The difference is noticeable right away. Not in a glaring, deal-breaking way…just in the subtle way you can tell this is built to hit a price point. The materials feel simple and straightforward…functional, but not premium. It’s not offensive, but if you’ve worn premium gear before, your hands will know the difference before your head ever does.

Think of it like buying a no-name kitchen knife versus a Wusthof. Both will cut your vegetables. Only one feels like a tool built to last a decade.

The DIAMOND 2 arrives in better shape out of the box, literally. It comes with a drawstring helmet bag. It’s not a fancy bag by any stretch, but it’s there, and it tells you something about how OutdoorMaster has positioned this helmet versus the ELK. The ELK comes with nothing extra. No bag, no accessories.

Here’s where things got interesting with the ELK: ours arrived with a broken ear piece, right out of the box, before it ever touched the slopes. A replacement was requested and received, and the replacement has held up fine through all of the testing with no issues since. But a quick scan of Amazon reviews confirms we weren’t alone. Other buyers have hit the same problem. And once you see why, it makes sense: the ELK’s ear piece is held on by a single one-inch hard plastic strap. That’s the whole connection point. One plastic strap. It’s the kind of design decision that makes you wonder what the conversation in the engineering meeting sounded like.

The DIAMOND 2 has a more secure, wider ear piece construction. It’s a much better solution, anchored by more than a single piece of plastic and a wish.

OutdoorMaster Ski Helmet Sizing: Buy With Confidence

One of the quiet anxieties of buying a helmet online is sizing. Get it wrong and you’re dealing with a return, a wait, and the whole process again. Good news here: OutdoorMaster’s size charts are accurate. Our testers measured squarely in the large range, ordered a large, and it fit perfectly for both of them on the first try.

Measure your head. Check the chart. Trust it. Sizes run:

• S (20.07–21.25 inches)
• M (21.65–22.83 inches)
• L (23.22–24.01 inches)

Comfort and Fit of the OutdoorMaster Ski Helmets: The Part That Surprised Us

Here’s the thing about both of these helmets: once they’re on your head, they’re comfortable. Not “fine for the price” comfortable. Actually comfortable.

The dial adjustment system on both helmets works well. Spin it, dial in your fit, done. It’s precise enough that you can fine-tune it meaningfully, not just toggle between “too loose” and “cuts off circulation.” Even with gloves on, it’s manageable.

Both helmets feature a fleece wrap around the chin strap, which is a small detail that pays off on cold days when bare plastic or webbing against your jaw is the last thing you want. The buckle is a standard plastic click-lock design. Nothing fancy, and it can be a bit awkward to work with gloves on, but that’s true of most helmets at this price point.

Both helmets have comfortable liners with a soft fleece interior that feels good against your face and head. If you’ve worn a high-end helmet before, you’ll still feel the difference. But if you’re coming from nothing or from an old hand-me-down, both of these will feel like a step up.

Our female tester’s take on the ELK was simple and, really, the best thing you can say about any piece of gear: once she was riding, she forgot it was there. It kept her warm, it fit well, and it did its job without demanding attention. She loved the Matte Pink color option too. The ELK’s 12-color lineup is a huge advantage if aesthetics matter to you.

Ventilation: Both Work, One Works Better

Both helmets have 8 vents and kept our testers comfortable across the temperature testing range, from around 14°F to 31°F, without any overheating or uncomfortable stuffiness. That’s a win.

The DIAMOND 2 has a toggle switch on top that opens and closes the vents, which turned out to be quite useful. As the sun went down and the temperature dropped, being able to close the vents and trap heat was a nice feature to have. Operating it with gloves on is a little fiddly but doable. Still, having the option beats not having it.

The ELK’s vents are fixed. They work, they breathe, but you’re committed to whatever conditions you’re in. Not a dealbreaker, just a step down in functionality.

OutdoorMaster Ski Helmet Goggle Compatibility: No Issues

Both helmets were tested with OutdoorMaster goggles and the pairing worked perfectly. No fogging, no serious gaps, no slippage. The goggle clip on the back of each helmet held things in place all day without adjustment. OutdoorMaster clearly designed these to work together, and it shows.

A Small Mystery: The ELK’s “Removable” Fleece Earpads

OutdoorMaster’s product listing for the ELK claims the fleece earpads are removable. After testing and a concerted effort to figure out how, we still couldn’t get them off. The inner liner does come out for washing, and that works fine. But the earpads themselves stayed put. **Update** The earpieces do come off it just takes quite a bit of force, video here of how to do it.

Safety: Certified and MIPS-Equipped

Both helmets carry ASTM F2040 and CE EN 1077 safety certifications, and both include MIPS, Multi-Directional Impact Protection System. MIPS is a real technology that meaningfully reduces rotational forces on the brain during certain types of impacts. It’s a safety feature you absolutely want, and having it included at this price point is impressive.

One thing worth saying clearly, regardless of which helmet you own: if you take a hard crash and your helmet absorbs a significant impact, replace it. This isn’t an OutdoorMaster-specific rule. It applies to every helmet at every price point. The foam and shell are designed to compress and absorb energy once. After a serious hit, that protection is gone even if the helmet looks fine on the outside. Treat a crash helmet like a used airbag. It did its job. Now retire it.

This is actually one of the more compelling arguments for a wallet-friendly helmet, something we’ll get into in the verdict.

The OutdoorMaster Ski Helmet Verdict: Good Enough Is Good Enough

Both of these helmets are good enough. Not “good enough for the price” as a way of letting them off the hook, but genuinely good enough to get you on the mountain safely, comfortably, and warm. They’re certified, MIPS-equipped, comfortable to wear all day, and available on Amazon Prime when you need one fast. That counts for a lot.

Are they in the same league as SMITH, Ruroc, or Giro? No. You’ll feel that difference the moment you put one on, and again after a few seasons of use. But that’s not the point of these helmets, and it shouldn’t be the measuring stick.

The right buyer for either of these is pretty clear. If you’re putting together your first ski kit and trying to do it without breaking the bank, either one will serve you well. If you need a helmet quickly and don’t want to spend $200 or more, these deliver. And if you’re the kind of skier who crashes hard and often and retires helmets the way you should, having a certified MIPS option at this price point stops being a compromise and starts being genuinely smart. Replacing a $70 helmet after a hard impact is a very different conversation than replacing a $250 one.

If we had to choose between the two, we’d lean toward the DIAMOND 2. The ear piece construction is more solid, the vent toggle is a useful feature on cold days, and it comes with a helmet bag. The ELK has had some quality control variability out of the box, though replacements are easy to come by and OutdoorMaster has been responsive on that front. Beyond that, both helmets do the job. Pick the color you like, get on the slope, and don’t look back. For more information or to pick one up for yourself, you can use discount code AGR15 at outdoormaster.com or grab one from amazon.com.